- Budgeters Anonymous
- Posts
- The Lose-Lose Housing Market
The Lose-Lose Housing Market
Rates, Prices, and What’s Next for Homebuyers & Sellers
Housing Market’s New Reality
The housing market is at a weird crossroads right now — and whether you’re trying to buy or sell, it’s worth paying attention.
Here’s what’s happening:
Mortgage rates have dipped from their recent highs but are still well above pandemic lows. This small drop is giving some buyers a little more breathing room, but not enough to dramatically change affordability.
Home prices are holding steady (or inching up) in many areas because inventory is still tight. Even with high rates, competition for good homes is keeping prices from falling.
The “lock-in effect” is real — millions of homeowners with sub-4% mortgages are staying put, keeping inventory low.
Affordability is still stretched — compared to the 1990s or early 2000s, today’s monthly payments for the same-priced home are hundreds (sometimes thousands) higher, mostly due to rates.
In short, it doesn’t feel like a great time for people who want to sell their home or for people who want to buy a home.
I’ve felt this squeeze personally.
My wife and I bought our home in 2022.
Since then, we’ve put a bunch of time and money into renovating and modernizing it — all done cost-effectively. We added value in every way we could.
But here’s the kicker: even with all that work, if we sold today, we’d lose a lot of money.
Home prices in our area have actually gone down. We’re “house rich” in the sense that we love where we live, but “trapped” in the sense that selling right now makes zero financial sense.
In this email, I wanted to break down some things to consider if you’re looking to buy a home or if you’re thinking about selling your home to buy another.
If you’re buying
Let’s be real, interest rates are still the biggest challenge.
Sure, they’ve come down a bit from their peak, but compared to a few years ago? They’re still pretty high. That means your monthly mortgage payment is going to feel a lot heavier.
So here’s the thing: don’t get hung up on the listing price.
What really matters is what you can comfortably afford every month once you add up taxes, insurance, and maintenance costs.
Affordability is king right now.
Affordability = 30% of your after-tax income - Dave Ramsey’s Calculator
You might have to shift your mindset a little. This might not be the moment to snag your “forever home.”
A lot of savvy buyers are going with a “buy now, upgrade later” strategy, getting their foot in the door without stretching themselves too thin.
And here’s some good news:
Sellers are feeling the heat with demand cooling off, which means you have more room to negotiate. Don’t be shy, ask for rate buydowns, closing cost help, or repairs. There’s often wiggle room.
Bottom line? Be smart, be patient, and focus on what makes sense for your wallet.
If you’re selling right now
I know it can feel tough out there.
Home prices in some areas have softened, and even if you’ve put a ton of work and love into your place, the market might not reflect that value yet.
So before you panic, remember this:
Timing and strategy are everything. You don’t want to rush and sell at a loss if you can avoid it, but you also don’t want to wait forever.
If you do need to sell now, focus on making your home as appealing as possible without breaking the bank. 25 ways to get curb appeal for less than $100
Small updates and great staging can make a big difference.
If selling now isn’t urgent, it might be worth waiting for the market to rebound a bit, especially if you’re planning to buy again soon.
I would also consider renting instead of selling. If you can make it work, renting your home for a year or two could make a huge difference if the market starts to change.
Even if it were to be for a slight loss. Imagine you rent out your place and lose $100/mo. But after two years, you’re able to sell it for $50k more.
You basically invested $2,400 (plus a little time) to make $50k.
When it comes to real estate, it’s about playing the long game, not just chasing quick wins.
Every market is different, so make sure you’re doing some research on your market specifically. Here are some signs that it is a seller market:
1 - Months of Inventory (MOI) = less than 3 months
2 - Average Days On Market = less than 30 days
3 - Seller to list price ratio = more than 98%
4 - Number of offers per listing = more than 2 to 3 offers
5 - Price Appreciation Rates = more than 5% per year
6 - More pending sales than new listings
Try looking up Housing Market Reports in your area on Google or talk to a realtor and they should be able to provide you this data.
That’s it for this week.
As always, if there is ever anything I can do, please let me know!
Dan the Budget Man
Reply